Batman Begins (2005)

Most of the comic book influences on Batman Begins are fairly evident. Everyone points to Frank Miller’s Year One, the redefining four-part series that put the “Dark” back in Dark Knight, and they’re right to hold that book up as the major influence. Begins relies heavily on Year One for a number of things, not least among them the exploration of the Bruce Wayne/Jim Gordon relationship, the exploration of the Bruce Wayne/Alfred relationship, the Gotham Monorail, the mention of the Joker at the end, the entire character of Flass, the entire sequence where Batman calls a squadron of bats to his aid (a bat-talion, am I right? Guys?) and, of course, the entire bat-flies-through-window genesis of the hero himself.

So Year One is the obvious one. Nolan and David Goyer pilfered little things from other famous Bat-books as well, often just an image or a line of dialogue. Here’s the Scarecrow in Loeb and Sale’s The Long Halloween, another popular arc:

Long Halloween
The Long Halloween (1996/97)

Goyer brought this to Nolan and said “I think Katie Holmes and the little kid who will eventually grow up to be Joffrey from Game of Thrones would look really good if we added them in front of the horse here” (paraphrased) and Nolan said “true dat, brah” (not paraphrased) and ran with it:

Batman Begins (2005)
Batman Begins (2005)

The red eyes and flames are an admittedly nice touch.

There are dozens of these moments, shoutouts to fans that actually work within the context of Nolan’s origin tale (most of the time). Year One does most of the heavy lifting, sure, and The Long Halloween would actually do the same for The Dark Knight. But although the general consensus is that Year One is the primary influence on Batman Begins while a healthy dose of iconography from Batman comic book lore is thrown in for good measure, I’d submit that there’s an arc that deserves every bit as much recognition for inspiring the Batman reboot (re-bat? Guys?) as Year One has received so far. That arc is now collectively known as Tales of the Demon.

This isn’t an “arc” in the way Year One or Long Halloween are arcs, as it’s not a continuously published neatly-packaged story. Tales of the Demon collects a handful of Batman vs. Ra’s al Ghul stories that ran in both the Batman and Detective Comics lines from 1971 to 1980, all of them written by Denny O’Neil and most of them illustrated by Neal Adams. Goyer has explicitly stated that the Ra’s stuff in Begins was taken primarily from the O’Neil/Adams days, yet the ties to Miller’s Year One seem to have eclipsed that statement where most fans are concerned.

My point is not just that you’ll see scenes from Tales of the Demon when you watch Batman Begins, although you will. The Batman/Ra’s sword fight that appears in “The Demon Lives Again!” is so iconic, in fact, that there’s an apparent need to pay homage to it every single time the pair square off against each other. This includes even the most recent Batman/Ra’s comics battle:

Batman Ra's Jim Lee

An episode of The Animated Series:

Batman Ra's Animated Series
Batman: The Animated Series (1992)

And — more than 30 years after Ra’s first appeared — Batman Begins:

Batman Begins (2005)
Batman Begins (2005)

It’s cold out in the Begins sword fight, but under all those clothes they’re almost certainly shirtless. The Bats/Ra’s duel is usually a great scene regardless of the medium, but no matter how many times it occurs it never seems to have the same forcefulness that Neal Adams and Denny O’Neil mustered in that first go-round:

"The Demon Lives Again!" (1972)
“The Demon Lives Again!” (1972)

That’s one of the greatest single-panel Do Not F*ck With Batman moments of all time. So yeah, Begins does the due diligence in recalling famous instances in Ra’s al Ghul comics lore, and certainly uses Tales of the Demon for some important visual touchpoints. It’s in that relationship, though — the complicated Bruce Wayne/Ra’s al Ghul student/mentor love/hate pairing that Tales of the Demon introduced — where Nolan’s Begins is most surefooted.

To be sure, the Ra’s we see in Begins is stripped of a great many characteristics that make him a compelling character in the comics. The literal immortality of Ra’s — bestowed on him in a fresh youthfulness upon emerging from a soak in his green-goo “Lazarus Pits” — is jettisoned in favor of Nolan’s signature realism. While certainly understandable, the decision means we never get to see Crazy Ra’s as his mind reforms upon rising from the Pit. A younger version of Ra’s actually was considered, as Nolan met with Memento star Guy Pearce about the role; Liam Neeson’s mentor Ra’s is ultimately more effective in the context of the film, though The Dark Knight Rises would provide an opportunity both for a Young Ra’s and a version of the Lazarus Pit to reach the silver screen.

In Begins, despite whatever inclusion or exclusion of famous comics imagery Nolan and Co. eventually decided on, the heart of Ra’s al Ghul’s character is definitely intact. Goyer had definitely read the issues collected in Tales of the Demon, and I wouldn’t be surprised if Neeson flipped through them as well — he captures the sophisticated thought-process of a very determined man with a very singular goal, and his Ra’s serves as the perfect blend of mental and physical prowess that would come to shape Bruce Wayne’s caped crusader. Year One provided the framework and a lot of the larger subplot arcs, but the character details evident in both the villain and the hero owe more to Tales of the Demon.

7 thoughts on “Batman Begins (2005)”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s